• * Register
  • * Login
  • * FAQ
  • Board index
Medical-specialists.co.uk
Board index ‹ General Weight Loss Discussions & information ‹ Weight Loss Advice

Weight Loss advice for over weight people
Post a reply
5 posts • Page 1 of 1

Why diets don't work?

Postby Bianca29 » Thu Jul 15, 2010 9:51 am

Let’s face it:

• We all know that overeating and sedentarism are the two main habits leading to weight gain.
• We all know that an apple is better for our figure than a burger.
• We are experts in counting calories, grams of fat, grams of carbs, points, etc.
• We know inside out all the popular diets.
• We buy the latest sugar-free shakes and bars, magic teas and lotions, slimming pants and pills.
Then, why is it that:
• the number of overweight people has been dramatically increasing during the past 30 years?
• up to two thirds of the weight is regained within one year after dieting, and almost all the lost weight is regained within five years?

Here is one of the closely-kept secrets that the MULTI, MULTI, MULTI BILLION dollars weight loss industry does not want you to know:

DIETS DO NOT ADDRESS THE REAL CAUSE OF YOUR PROBLEM

and, as a consequence,

DIETS CANNOT HELP YOU MAINTAIN A LONG LASTING WEIGHT LOSS!

Diets require us to rectify our habits (eg: overeating habit, unhealthy eating habit, sedentarism).

Habits are behaviours which have been done so regularly than are eventually being performed without thinking/ without requiring active attention.

Repeated behaviours (eg: overeating habit) are the visible cause of results (eg: weight gain).

All behaviours have a cause on their own:
• innate drives (eg: hunger, thirst) or
• emotions (love, pain, fear, anger, stress)

Emotions are often a result of beliefs.

Beliefs are thoughts accepted as being true (eg: eating is my only way of coping with neglect).

Beliefs are determined by external stimuli, by events (eg: being constantly neglected).

Imagine this:

The events which determined your weight gain are like the seed of a fruit tree. The strong roots of the fruit tree, springing from the seed, are your deeply embedded beliefs about what those events meant to you. The trunk of the tree represents your emotions. The branches of the tree represent your weight gain habits and the fruits are your results. Without roots, there’s no trunk. Without branches, there’s no fruit. Correct?


The seed of weight gain resides in past events:

• Boredom
• Being spoiled with sweets
• Dieting
• Betrayal
• Early maturation
• Loss of loved ones
• Lack of work and relaxation balance
• Abuse
• Neglect
• Rejection
• Anger

The roots of your weight gain are your beliefs created by past events (seeds). Events (eg: being neglected) can lead us to build beliefs about ourselves (eg: unworthy of love), even when the events say nothing about ourselves (eg: neglected by a highly stressed and busy parent who is working hard to provide as much as possible for his child).

The trunk of your weight gain is the emotion (eg: feeling unwanted) that your belief about yourself (eg: unworthy of love) makes you feel (eg: feeling lonely).

Your Weight Gain Feeders

Your beliefs have led you to make certain choices and have certain expectations in life. Choices and expectations confirm and maintain your beliefs. We always settle for what you believe we deserve.

For example, if abuse has led you to believe that you are unworthy of love, this will be reflected by the type of romantic relation you choose. You are more susceptible to accept being neglected or abused, because, as you believe that you are unworthy of love, you have no expectations for a loving relation.

Staying in an abusive relation will maintain your belief, as abuse will make you constantly feel unworthy of love. If you have always found comfort from abuse in eating, this habit will be perpetuated because of this abusive relation you are trapped in.Examples of Weight Gain Feeders:

1. Your past and present choices in life: lousy/ abusive romantic relation, boring job, diets obsession, fear of being yourself, feeling like a victim, self-imposed isolation, shyness, shame of being different, self-hatred, etc.

2. Your future expectations: no hope for having a fulfilling romantic relation, no hope for finding an enjoyable job, no hope for being truly, madly, deeply happy, etc.
Bianca29
 
Posts: 10
Joined: Thu Jul 15, 2010 9:17 am
Top

Re: Why diets don't work?

Postby cherieang » Fri Nov 05, 2010 4:15 am

Once you start dieting for weight loss, you will need to know weight management is long term process. If you really need to lose weight, then the process will be long term. After you lose weight, you will still need to maintain the weight that you have lost previously. It will change your lifestyle for the rest of your life.
cherieang
 
Posts: 22
Joined: Tue Nov 02, 2010 1:28 am
Top

Re: Why diets don't work?

Postby bigman » Tue May 31, 2011 9:08 pm

HI,I HAVE SPENT ALL MY LIFE TRYING TO DEAL WITH MY WEIGHT PROBLEM.

IF YOU HAVE PROBLEMS WITH DRINK, DRUGS OR SMOKING, THE NHS PROVIDES MUCH HELP AND ASSISTANCE.

IF YOU HAVE A REAL WEIGHT PROBLEM, DIETS, DRUGS OR SURGERY SEEMS TO BE THE ONLY OPTIONS?

I WOULD LIKE THE NHS TO CONSIDER SETTING UP A FAT FARM RETREAT TO HELP BREAK THE CYCLE WITH VIEW TO PROVIDING PROPER ADVICE, EXERCISE AND DIET FOR THE INDIVIDUAL.

I'M SURE THIS MUST BE BETTER THAN THE OPERATING TABLE OR YEARS ON DRUGS?

DOES ANYBODY AGREE?
bigman
 
Posts: 1
Joined: Tue May 31, 2011 8:09 pm
Top

Re: Why diets don't work?

Postby Paul1 » Sun Jun 05, 2011 8:16 pm

Well I just typed out a whole thing and the damn forum logged me off. There's no way I'm gonna write it out again. But basically I disagree, it's related to our sedentary lifestyle. Being sedentary is physiologically linked to our immune metabolic and stress response, in order to force us to rest for recovery. By being sedentary most of the time, our immune metabolic and stress responses keep being activated. In our caveman days this was a life saver, but in our modern times this is actually working against us. Evolution basically hasn't kept up. Prolonged stress leads to mental health disorders such as depression and anxiety. The response speeds up your metabolism, but when not ill this causes weight gain as you clamber for more food when hungry.

The best solution is exercise. Even just 30 minutes brisk walk each day is enough to help. 20% of the population do less than 10 minutes of vigorous exercise per week. We simply never evolved to live like this.

Certain types of mental health disorders do increase cravings for carbohydrates. Those health issues need to be treated, but that can take a while in some cases. Treating the symptoms in the mean time can really help, not only loosing weight but in being more happy. Exercising just 15 minutes has been shown to reduce carbohydrate cravings and also helping mood. Hunger can cause low mood, so eating low GI carbohydrates and fat can help prevent hunger, which is better than continuously eating bad sugary foods. Tiredness can cause hunger, if depression/anxiety is affecting sleep, visit the doctor to get help for sleeping.

Most importantly, exercise, even if it's just a half hour walk.

I think I'm gonna go on a diet based on my own advice to see if it works.
Paul1
 
Posts: 1
Joined: Sun Jun 05, 2011 3:49 pm
Top

Re: Why diets don't work?

Postby jannet » Fri Jan 06, 2012 6:10 am

The main reason it that we not do it consistently and properly as we should do to achieve our optimum goal....
jannet
 
Posts: 44
Joined: Thu Jun 02, 2011 11:25 am
Location: West Palm Beach Florida
  • Website
Top


Post a reply
5 posts • Page 1 of 1

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 30 guests

  • Change font size
  • Print view
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
Style created by David Jansen @ IDLaunch